Among
the various tangible asset alternatives, two stand
out – rare coins and precious metals. Both
are lasting tangible assets with an impressive record
of extraordinary returns. A balanced portfolio of
rare coins and precious metals offers 8 important
benefits that can enable individuals to increase
and protect their wealth in a variety of economic
and political circumstances in the years to come.
Benefit
One - Outstanding Investment Performance
Rare coins
have demonstrated remarkable long-term performance. This performance is a result of simple
fundamentals in the rare coin marketplace. The last
rare coin to be minted left the coin press decades
ago. So supplies can be described as static, or
even diminishing, as coins are lost or taken off
the market and put into museums or long-term collections
and family estates. Meanwhile, demand is accelerating.
New stockpiles
of gold and silver are being mined every year, but
no one can make any more rare coins. This finite
supply is one of the keys to rare coins’ successful
track record. This track record can be demonstrated
by a variety of both empirical and anecdotal evidence.
Chart
1 shows the outstanding appreciation of a broad
index of key dates and rarities index of rare U.S.
coins over a period of nearly 35 years Next, Chart
2 shows the same index over a period of 10 years.
Finally, Chart
3 shows this index over the past 3 years. Each
of these charts graphically demonstrates a pattern
of consistent growth and performance
over varying periods of time.
But, in
addition to these indices, there are actual real-world
examples of exceptional coin market performance.
For example, Chart
4 shows that record auction prices for some
of the world’s rarest coins have consistently
risen since 1974.
In addition
to the illustrious examples depicted in Chart
4, there are numerous other real-world examples
of outstanding rare coin market performance.
Whole collections
of rare coins accumulated over time have also produced
handsome returns for their owners, as these real-world
examples show:
•The
John Jay Pittman Collection: John Jay Pittman was
a chemical engineer for Kodak who happened to have
a great passion for scarce gold and silver coins.
However, he was not an exceptionally wealthy man
and, over his entire lifetime, he spent a total
of about $100,000 on his collection. Astonishingly,
that collection sold at auction in the late 1990s
for nearly $30 million!
•The
Harold Bareford Collection: From 1947 to 1954, Harold
Bareford spent $13,382 on his coin collection. In
1978, that collection sold at auction for $1.2 million!
•The
Eliasberg Collection: From 1925 to 1976, Louis Eliasberg
accumulated the greatest coin collection on record.
His cost basis was $300,000. The collection sold
at auction for $12.4 million in 1982! All of the
examples detailed above demonstrate the incredible,
proven track record of rare coins as an outstanding
long-term investment.
Benefit
Two -Diversification
Rare coins
belong in every investment portfolio because they
tend to “zig” when most other investments
“zag.”
As explained
in the introduction to this report, true diversification
requires that a collector compile a portfolio mix
of assets that are not positively correlated with
one another. Tangible assets, gold collections in
particular, are negatively correlated to stocks,
bonds and the U.S. dollar. This means that they
can help reduce the overall portfolio volatility
of the typical portfolio.
A high-profile
example occurred in 2002 when the 1933 Saint-Gaudens
Double Eagle shattered auction records by fetching
$7.6 million at the same time that the U.S. economy
was struggling and the U.S. stock market was staggered
under the weight of corporate malfeasance scandals
and the September 11th attacks.
Rare gold
coins are superior to gold bullion. Historically,
rare gold coins have shown a much higher rate of
return than gold. This is because rare coins do
not need a rising gold price to turn in bull market
performance. However, there has never been bull
market in gold in which rare coins did not also
have a bull market.
Rare coins
have performed well when gold has not:
•
From 1987 to 1990, gold fell from $500 to $360 per
ounce. During this same period, the rare coin market
went up 300%.
But rare
coins can even outperform bullion in a gold bull
market:
•
In its record setting year, 1980, the price of gold
rose from $550 to $850 per ounce . But in that same
period, the market for rare gold coins climbed by
1,000%.
(Graph
1) Graysheet and its supplements as published
in Coin World
Benefit
Three - Privacy
Rare coin
transactions are truly paperless. And, as collectibles,
there are no broker reporting requirements for rare
coin purchases. In today’s environment of
frivolous law suits and instant availability of
personal information over the internet, rare coins
can be a great benefit as a truly private purchase
for those who do not want everyone else to know
what they own.
Benefit
Four - Liquidity
Certified
rare coins are the most liquid collectible assets all.
Select common
and scarce coins trade electronically – sight
unseen – on an electronic exchange, very similar
to NASDAQ. In addition to this network, there are
literally thousands of coin dealers across America
that can provide owners of rare coins even more
power to liquidate and trade their coins. Finally,
millions of dollars worth of rare coins trade each
year at hundreds of coin shows, conventions and
auctions held from coast to coast.
The electronic
trading network and other aspects of the high liquidity
of the rare coin market have been made possible
by the advent of independent grading and certification
by the two major grading services, PCGS (Professional
Coin Grading Service) and NGC (Numismatic Guaranty
Corporation). These excellent firms were founded
in the 1980s and immediately transformed the numismatic
industry.
Since their
founding they have graded literally tens of millions
of coins.
Benefit
Five - Portability
Rare coins
are extremely portable, tangible storehouses of
wealth. They are an ideal way to concentrate a great
deal of wealth privately in a small package. Coin
owners can easily place thousands—even millions—of
dollars of wealth in their pocket for easy, concealed
transport from financial center to financial center,
or for any reason.
Admiration
and enjoyment of superb and valuable objects and
works of art have long been one of man’s great
qualities. This kind of passion is what motivates
collectors to bid millions of dollars
on a Picasso.
But you
would never be able to discretely and securely walk
the city streets of America carrying a Picasso.
Rare coins, on the other hand, are perfectly suited
for discrete transport.
Benefit Six
- Affordability
Unlike many
collectible assets, rare coins are well within
the reach of most people. Even though some rare
coins have traded at auction for millions of dollars,
anyone can start a collection of truly rare
coins with just a few thousand dollars.
Benefit Seven
- Intrinsic Value
Gold and
silver rare coins offer the additional security
of their intrinsic value. Unlike paper assets
or collectible investments such as art, stamps,
rare documents or currency, gold and silver coins
can never become worthless.
Benefit Eight
- Beauty & History
In addition
to the “crass profit motive,” rare coins
are characterized by a different, ethereal value.
This value should not be taken lightly because it
forms the basis of coins’ appeal to collectors,
who are the foundation of the entire numismatic
market.
Once a collector
acquires a coin, he or she often finds it difficult
to part with it. Once they hold the coin in their
hands, it becomes very hard to decide to sell it.
This phenomenon is significant for the buyer
because it means that many collectors will retain
their collections almost indefinitely. This contributes
to rare coins’ merit as assets by further
limiting the available supply on the market. |